Jordan Chiles' Bronze Medal Controversy Explained
Language
Reading Level
Listen to Article
Alignment
US gymnast Jordan Chiles is at the center of an unusual controversy. The 23-year-old is being asked to return her Olympic bronze medal due to the timing of an appeal filed by her coach. The chain of events leading to this unprecedented decision unfolded shortly after the individual floor exercise final on August 5, 2024.
Chiles initially received a score of 13.666, placing her fifth. However, her coach, Cecile Landi, appealed the scoring of one element in her routine. The judges agreed and increased Chiles' score by 0.1 to 13.766. This minor adjustment put her in third place, ahead of Romanian gymnasts Ana Bǎrbosu and Sabrina Maneca-Voinea, who both scored 13.700. Since Bǎrbosu had a higher technical score, she was the original recipient of the bronze medal.
However, shortly after the medal ceremony, Romanian officials filed a challenge. They alleged that Team USA's scoring inquiry exceeded the one-minute deadline by four seconds. On August 10, 2024, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) agreed with their appeal. They ruled that the original scores be reinstated, putting Chiles back in fifth place.
Following the CAS ruling, the US and Romania proposed awarding bronze medals to both Chiles and Bǎrbosu. However, on August 11, 2024, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) rejected this request. They asked Chiles to return her bronze medal so it could be given to Bǎrbosu.
Undeterred, USA Gymnastics filed another appeal with CAS. This time they provided a time-stamped video. The footage revealed Landi submitting two inquiries: one 47 seconds and another 55 seconds after the initial score was posted. However, CAS rejected the request. They stated that the rules did not allow them to reconsider a decision even if there was new evidence. On August 16, 2024, Bǎrbosu received the bronze medal in a ceremony held in Bucharest, Romania.
Meanwhile USA Gymnastics continues to challenge the decision. They next plan to appeal to the Swiss Federal Supreme Court, which holds the authority to overturn the CAS decision. Jordan Chiles, who has yet to return the medal, remains hopeful about the outcome.
"I will approach this challenge as I have others — and will make every effort to ensure that justice is done," Chiles said. "I believe that at the end of this journey, the people in control will do the right thing."
Resources: CNN.com, Sportingnews.com, theGuardian.com
Get the Workbook for this article!
Workbook contains: Article, Reading Comprehension, Critical Thinking Questions, Vocabulary in Context (+ answers), Multiple Choice Quiz (+ answers), Parts of Speech Quiz (+ answers), Vocabulary Game (+ answers)Cite Article
Learn Keywords in this Article
27 Comments
- meeboo318 daysI SAD
- finleeabout 2 monthsNot fair she is the best
malach2 monthsthis is amazing
ellie27102 monthsThis poor girl really deserved it. They should just have 2 bronze if they don't agree. Like meet in the middle kinda thing.
ravenaa59593 monthsDon't look back. You’re not going that way.🤗- ravenaa59593 monthsWhat doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.💪
love-art3 monthsthats sooo sad but hopefully she can come back next Olympics!! 🙏🏻
ejeanpierre3 monthswhy did they do that I report this is unjustice
dogozoey3 monthsThis is so unreal. Like one second it is there and the next it is being taken away from her if they can.
emmaanna3 monthsI can't belive that medal was just taken away from her. THIS IS UNJUSTCE! 😟
